Dollar’s Trouble Could Be Gold’s Triumph

Monthly gold market and economic insights from Imaru Casanova, Portfolio Manager, featuring her unique views on mining and gold’s portfolio benefits.

Gold’s Record Highs and Market Drivers

Gold continued its upward trajectory in February, reaching a record high of $2,951.73 per ounce on 24 February, driven by safe-haven demand amid concerns over U.S. trade policy. The Trump administration’s policy induced uncertainty, combined with rising inflation expectations and diminished consumer confidence, weighed on major stock indexes, further boosting gold’s appeal as an alternative investment and portfolio diversifier.

A key factor behind gold’s latest rally was a surge in the holdings of gold bullion backed ETFs. Total known ETF holdings of gold increased by 2.49% in February, marking the largest monthly inflow since March 2022¹. However, profit-taking and a strengthening U.S. dollar in the final week of February triggered a pullback, pushing gold down by approximately $100 from its peak. Despite this decline, gold closed at $2,857.83 per ounce on 28 February, securing a monthly gain of $59.42, or 2.12%. As of 7 March, gold prices have risen by 77.5% over the past five years². Investors should be aware of the risks associated with investing in gold, such as market volatility, potential for price declines, and currency fluctuations.

Performance and Investor Sentiment

The NYSE Arca Gold Miners Index (GDMNTR) gained 2.01% in February³, performing significantly better than the broader equity markets, but ultimately falling short of matching the metal’s gains. However, year to date, gold equities have demonstrated relatively strong leverage to gold prices, rising 17.22% compared to bullion’s 8.89% gain. Keep in mind that past performance is not indicative of future results.

This mixed performance was a key topic at the annual BMO Metals and Mining conference in Florida this past month. Optimism about the sector was met with frustration, as rising cash balances, improved liquidity, lower debt ratios, higher dividends and significant buyback programs have failed to spark investor interest in the past years. That trend may be set to change in 2025, as growing investment demand for gold, evidenced by inflows into the bullion ETFs, should also lead to increased demand for gold equities. Anecdotally, companies at the conference reported an increased number of meetings with general investors eager to reduce their near-zero exposure to gold⁴.

Resilience Amid Global Tariffs

The gold industry remains largely isolated from the negative impact of global tariffs. In fact, many gold producers could benefit from foreign currency depreciations triggered by these tariffs, as a significant portion of their cost base is denominated in local currencies. For example, Alamos Gold estimates that about 90-95% of its Canadian operational costs are Canadian dollar denominated, while about 40-45% of its Mexican mine expenses are denominated in pesos⁵. While industry cost inflation is widely reported around the 3-5% range for 2025⁶, the potential benefit of weaker local currencies and a rising gold price could more than offset inflationary pressures for the sector. This dynamic could continue to drive margin expansion to new record levels.

The Evolving Role of the U.S. Dollar and Emerging Trends

For more than a century, the U.S. dollar has been the cornerstone of the global financial system. Most trade is financed in U.S. dollars, commodities are priced in U.S. dollars and the U.S. dollar has been used, coveted and hoarded by people and nations around the world. However, this could change.

The U.S. dollar’s strength against other currencies has traditionally been supported by the robustness of the U.S. economy and its reputation as one of the safest jurisdictions in which to invest.

The chart below highlights a steady long-term upward trend of the U.S. Dollar Index amid fluctuations in recent years.

U.S. Dollar Strength, 2008 to 2025

Source: FactSet. Data as of 12 February 2025. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. Index performance is not representative of strategy performance. It is not possible to invest in an index.

Despite its strength, the dollar has been devaluing relative to gold—an unprecedented trend that few view as a threat to the currency or sign of a precipitated crisis.

Historically, gold bull markets have been driven by three things:

1. Runaway inflation – gold surged 1500% in the 1970s
2. A failing dollar – gold climbed 302% from 2001 to 2008
3. Financial crises – gold increased 134% from 2008 to 2011

The current gold bull market, which began in 2016, is remarkable because it is not accompanied by U.S. dollar weakness or a global financial crisis. While the pandemic was a crisis, its financial impact was short-lived, thanks to massive government intervention.

Erosion of Confidence in the Dollar

Another driver has emerged: people and nations that have long used, coveted and hoarded the U.S. dollar could now be losing faith and trust in the currency as a store of wealth. This shift began in 2008 when the global financial crisis led many to question the efficacy of the banking system and western economic hegemony. It escalated with sanctions and freezing of assets imposed on Russia by the U.S. Other countries fear that similar retribution or “weaponization of the dollar” is possible for lesser infractions than the hostile invasion of another country. Now tariffs have been weaponized. Gold has gained 275% since Lehman Brothers failed in 2008 and 50% since Russia invaded Ukraine in 2022. Additionally, irresponsible fiscal policies and political chaos in the U.S. suggest that one or more of the traditional drivers of gold may reemerge. As a result, the world is slowly and methodically moving away from the dollar, a shift most evident in changes to currency reserves and increased central bank gold purchases.

China has been exiting U.S. Treasuries while increasing its gold:

China's US Treasury Holdings vs. Gold Reserves (2013-2014)

Source: Bloomberg. Data as of December 2024.

Source: Metals Focus, LSEG Data & Analytics (formerly Refinitiv), ICE Benchmark Administration, and World Gold Council. Data as of December 2024.

We believe this could mark the start of longer-term trends that might become recognized as a crisis of confidence in the U.S. dollar, potentially driving gold prices much higher than many expect. If a digital asset like Bitcoin, created and residing within servers, can be valued at $100,000, then surely an ounce of a tangible, reliable safe-haven asset like gold could reach a small fraction of that value.

To receive more Gold Investing insights, sign up to our newsletter.